One year later, the Yankees’ broadcasters have addressed the controversy sparked by the Jays’ pregame show last season, where they suggested Aaron Judge had illicitly peeked at the dugout, prompting calls for him to be targeted in retaliation.

During Wednesday afternoon’s game, with the Yankees trailing 2-0 to the Blue Jays and trying to avoid a sweep, Kay made a candid comment that probably should have stayed off-air. He noted Toronto’s impressive two-strike approach in the series, particularly their ability to wear down Carlos Rodón by fouling off numerous hard fastballs. Despite Rodón’s increased velocity, the Jays managed to tire him out by fouling off 27 pitches. Kay expressed surprise at this improved discipline from the Jays, contrasting it with their performance just 10 days earlier at Yankee Stadium, where they appeared to lack such patience at the plate.

Kay’s remarks suggested skepticism about Toronto’s sudden transformation in offensive discipline, hinting at possible cheating without explicitly stating it. While his comments may have reflected frustration with the Yankees’ performance, they raised eyebrows for insinuating foul play by the Blue Jays.

For those who remember Toronto’s excuses during the “Fat Boy” series in May 2023, Kay’s implications may be difficult to support, especially considering the Yankees’ own history of home-field controversies. However, it’s unlikely that fans will rally behind Kay’s accusations, and it’s best to let him defend his position on this matter.